I take it that you have not attended any of the science meetings

Space/Science » in reply to Re: ALH84001.

Alex R. Blackwell — 5/15/2002 1:52:43 PM (archived)

that Nick refers to? The negative reaction to McKay et al. is both real and vehement, not to mention well documented. That said, I would hardly agree with you that McKay et al.'s reputation has been "enhanced," except of course among the "true believers."

Alex R. Blackwell
University of Hawaii

The whole thread (20 posts)

Resolution of a Big Argument About Tiny Magnetic Minerals in Martian Meteorite (con't) - Alex R. Blackwell - 5/15/2002 4:39:20 PM
- Re: Resolution of a Big Argument About Tiny Magnetic Minerals in Martian Meteorite (con't) - Robert Clark - 5/15/2002 7:59:08 PM
  - Re: Resolution of a Big Argument About Tiny Magnetic Minerals in Martian Meteorite (con't) - Alex R. Blackwell - 5/15/2002 8:05:59 AM
    - Re: Resolution of a Big Argument About Tiny Magnetic Minerals in Martian Meteorite (con't) - Robert Clark - 5/15/2002 8:35:11 AM
      - Re: Resolution of a Big Argument About Tiny Magnetic Minerals in Martian Meteorite (con't) - Alex R. Blackwell - 5/15/2002 8:41:31 AM
        
        Re: Resolution of a Big Argument About Tiny Magnetic Minerals in Martian Meteorite (con't) - Robert Clark - 5/15/2002 1:31:52 PM
        
        Only the "true believers" in McKay et al. subscribe to this view... - Alex R. Blackwell - 5/15/2002 1:50:13 PM
        
        Re: Only the true believers ... - Robert Clark - 5/16/2002 7:57:16 PM
        
        Robert "Gandhi" Clark - Alex R. Blackwell - 5/16/2002 5:06:50 PM
- Occam's Razor - LJ - 5/15/2002 7:28:29 PM
  - Wielding (a double-edged) Occam's Razor - Alex R. Blackwell - 5/15/2002 8:00:25 AM
    - Re: Wielding (a double-edged) Occam's Razor - LJ - 5/15/2002 9:35:14 AM
- "Admittedly, Trieman is a sceptic"... - Nick Hoffman - 5/15/2002 10:21:22 AM
  - The way it happened - E.P. Grondine - 5/16/2002 8:48:31 AM
  - Re: ALH84001. - Robert Clark - 5/15/2002 1:26:32 PM
    - I take it that you have not attended any of the science meetings - Alex R. Blackwell - 5/15/2002 1:52:43 PM
      - Re: I take it that you have not attended any of the science meetings - Robert Clark - 5/16/2002 7:11:16 PM
        
        Re: I take it that you have not attended any of the science meetings - Alex R. Blackwell - 5/16/2002 5:44:24 PM
  - Restrained debate - Alex R. Blackwell - 5/15/2002 10:37:14 AM
    - Re: Restrained debate - Nick Hoffman - 5/15/2002 6:11:53 PM

Recent posts

On this day in Space/Science

The whole thread (20 posts)