Space/Science — HabitableZone

Space/Science » in reply to re: Well -- ‘Cat Who Walks Through Walls’ mismatch

re: Thank you, Angus MacGyver . . . ;^)

Sorry, but MacGyver happens to be on right now.

I'd say a human being should be able to do at least 15 of the 21 tasks (a far cry from "specialization", or "insects"), but still a very effective example of the species. And I'm a pretty fair rail-splitter and can set a nice 5-rail fence -- among other things.

A human being should be able to:
* change a diaper


Hell, yes!

* plan an invasion

Can do.

* butcher a hog

Never tried -- or been that hungry.

* conn a ship

Cannot do (AKA untrained).

* design a building

Can do -- well, it was a two-car garage.

* write a sonnet

Can do.

* balance accounts

Can do.

* build a wall

Can do.

* set a bone

Can do.

* comfort the dying

Can do.

* take orders

Can do.

* give orders

Can do.

* cooperate

Can do.

* act alone

Can do.

* solve equations

Can do -- but limited.

* analyze a new problem

Can do.

* pitch manure

Can do.

* program a computer

Can do.

* cook a tasty meal

Can do.

* fight efficiently

Can do.

So, I guess 18 out of the 21 ain’t all that bad.

The 22nd, though -- die gallantly -- I think needs a lot of work. Dying is the most personal thing a person will ever go through. It preys in the human subconscious, with roots buried deep in family/tribal beliefs, dreams, hopes, and fears. And many don't have the opportunity to consider how they handle it. I don’t see dying nearly as important as living. It’s what’s left behind that matters to the world, whereas a person‘s death is entirely his or her own.

Then again, Heinlein did get a bit -- strange -- toward the end, with a definite passion for that evolutionary quirk called Renaissance Man... An enjoyable, or at least interesting, storyteller nonetheless.

Which book was the list derived from?

Dan

Log in or register to post.

The whole thread (15 posts)