...bunch of kefiya'd AK-47-brandishing Libyan rebels standing over Qaddafi's corpse, grinning sheepishly, muttering the equivalent of "oh look, Qaddafi, and he's dead! Where did that corpse come from?"

Sic semper tyrannis...you're right on all the procedural points, but nevertheless that's the shit that happens to people who choose Qaddafi's path. I'd say that Saddam was treated with exceptional civility, while Moammar's fate was more in line with longstanding tradition.

Qaddafi died the death he both deserved and expected. I seriously doubt he died with a look of surprise on his face.