Off Topic — HabitableZone

Off Topic

Andrew Sullivan on Susan Sontag

In case anyone missed Sullivan's deconstruction of Sontag's column.

From the end of Sullivan's column:

Sontag: "America has every right to hunt down the perpetrators of these crimes and their accomplices. But this determination is not necessarily a war. Limited, focused military engagements do not translate into "wartime" at home. There are better ways to check America's enemies, less destructive of constitutional rights and of international agreements that serve the public interest of all, than continuing to invoke the dangerous, lobotomizing notion of endless war."



Sullivan: "Lobotomizing? Isn't it telling that in her last fusillade against her opponents, she accuses them of facilitating a mass coma of stupidity? It is the last resort of the fading intellectual: to accuse your public of stupidity. Of course, it is Sontag who is drowning here. She knows she cannot countenance the evil of radical Islamism. She knows she cannot defend Saddam or Osama. She knows she cannot truly oppose self-defense against the horrors of the terror masters. For how can she be a real lefty and support people who enslave women, deny human rights and murder homosexuals and Jews? But her worldview is so marinated in decades of anti-Americanism, in a loathing of capitalism, of free markets, of free trade and ideas, that she cannot bring herself to live up to her own principles. So she waits in a welter of metaphor until they murder us again.



A worldview so marinated in decades of anti-Americanism, in a loathing of capitalism, of free markets, of free trade and ideas, that one cannot bring herself to live up to one's own principles. Sound like any others we know?

Log in or register to post.

The whole thread