Space/Science — HabitableZone

Space/Science » in reply to The Outer Solar System Can Be Ours!

Re: The Outer Solar System Can Be Ours!

One of the main reasons why the Solar System hasd been isolated is that more money has been spent on pork technology like VASIMR than actual missions; & that the cost benefit analysis of this work after the fact has generally proven to be extremely poor. Look at SEP-related technology: true, it makes medium delta v missions like Dawn more feasible; but it isn't even necessary for a Mercury orbiter (qv Messenger). Apart from some sample return architectures, it has little value for Mars & Venus missions, is almost useless for the Moon (pace SMART-1); & even with medium term extensions of our solar power technology, will struggle to operate at Jovian distances much less out in deep space.

(Didn't stop a bunch of labs fighting over the deep space propulsion initiative; especially when it was decided that a good use for the first year's budget was putting up a bunch of buildings instead of actually doing any research. With the money already allocated by Congress, the cash which has already been wasted on the propulsion initiative would pay a fair slab of the short term New Horizons cost)

VASIMR is the same: a vaguely plausible SEP derivative with few obvious markets in real world space programming; but plenty of press releases to make it look almost useful. Like all SEP systems (only more so), it's too inflexibly bulky for most robotic missions; unnecessary for manned flights (notwithstanding Dr Chang-Diaz's sometimes fruity claims), it's a solution in desperate search of a problem that can justify the huge expenditures required to even demonstrate that the system might be work; & is therefore only being given a starvation funding by space agencies. That's all its worth at this stage.

Bear in mind, however: there are plenty of good deep space missions which could be flown using off-the-shelf technology if labs were more interested in flying missions than building buildings & creating labs.

Neptune & Uranus fast flybys deploying small atmsopheric probes are perfectly feasible using buses based on New Horizons & its rival, POSSE; & would generate massive science returns on a budget.

Existing SEP-powered systems (ie, none of this advanced propulsion vaporware) can easily reach Jovian Trojans & could be used as a disposable part propulsion for a Centaur mission; & (closer to home) could supply the full delta v for a comet orbiter & probably sample return as well (asteroid sample returns are also quite easy with SEP-based systems).

Of course: if someone would sepent a few millions (not billions) to properly spacerate a small sail, then our options would really expand.

Robert

Log in or register to post.

The whole thread (12 posts)