Space/Science — HabitableZone

Space/Science » in reply to Numbers for R.L. and a note for Sam.

More Johannes Bulldust

Johannes, we've been through this before.

You're not just wrong, you're so stupidly wrong it's funny.

I won't bother debunking your post in detail, but in essence you have fallen into the standard "strawman" trap.

You have built a flimsy hypothesis, then, in demolishing it, you claim support for an alternative model which is in fact almost as flimsy.

As a simple but fundamental example of the depth of your error, allow me to point out that the early Earth (surface and atmosphere) was, if anything, COLDER than today, not warmer, due to the Faint Young Sun.

The rest of your argument is equally fallacious, ill-founded, self-serving, unscientific, illogical, inconsentent and innumerate.

In short, it is total BULLSHIT, and you are a prime bullshit artiste.

Log in or register to post.

The whole thread (11 posts)