Current Events — HabitableZone

Current Events » in reply to My neighbor is deaf.

Re: My neighbor is deaf.

<...ASL is very rich, there is a grammatical structure, and it seems to me there is a lot of information in the way something is presented, too. Hardly anything is presented by spelling.

One of my distant relatives is deaf, and uses ASL, which I don't know myself. What I found fascinating were ASL "puns," which combine visual and verbal in a way that cannot be translated into pure verbal language. Needless to say, I don't get any of them.

...My neighbor is one who is adamant that there is a deaf culture, and things like cochlear implants are not OK and designed to eradicate that culture. After having been around them I can see his point. Couldn't before, though, and don't know how much I agree. He does fine.

This sounds a little bizarre to me, and dangerously close to our current Culture of the Victim which seems to attract so many groups. Would a cure for AIDS eradicate an "AIDS culture?" I can't understand this kind of thinking at all. Maybe this helps him mentally get around some kind of complex about being "handicapped." Beats me.

Log in or register to post.

The whole thread (13 posts)