What Comet Coincides With Hoyle's attempt To Link Flu With Space?

Space/Science » in reply to re: Water/Ice comets much larger than igneous meteor fragments from Mars

What Comet Coincides With Hoyle's attempt To Link Flu With Space?

Mark Eby — 9/26/2003 3:25:31 PM (archived)

Please provide a link or reference indicating Hoyle only thought panspermia ONLY occurred through comets or that his space flu theory you tout so often depends on comets. Then provide a link or reference indicating that ANY known comet was ever identified as being extra-solar. We are pretty sure these exist, but as far as I know they are expected to be extremely rare and there is no way they can be linked to flu outbreaks.

One of the pseudoscince BS detector points is that all the links in a logic chain must fit together or the whole chain is false.

Regards,
Mark

The whole thread (48 posts)

"Why A Mars Rock Lands On Earth Every Month" aka why BD is full of .... - Buster - 9/19/2003 1:52:36 PM
- re: "Why A Mars Rock Lands On Earth Every Month" aka why BD is full of .... - BD - 9/23/2003 11:57:03 PM
  - I already know you are a stupid parrot BD - Buster - 9/24/2003 1:40:36 AM
- Interesting article, but... - Don - 9/20/2003 6:09:59 PM
  - So Let Me Get This Straight - Mark Eby - 9/20/2003 7:57:31 PM
    - Getting straight - Don - 9/20/2003 8:45:27 PM
      - re: Getting straight - Mark Eby - 9/22/2003 1:56:00 AM
        
        re: Getting straight - Greg - 9/22/2003 4:30:52 AM
        
        re: Getting straight on Martian meteorites - BD - 9/23/2003 11:53:18 PM
        
        Clear evidence BD has no integrity - Buster - 9/24/2003 10:31:00 PM
        
        re: Clear evidence BD has no integrity - Greg - 9/25/2003 3:27:28 AM
        
        re: Clear evidence BD has no integrity - Robert Clark - 9/26/2003 2:20:43 AM
        
        re: Clear evidence BD has no integrity - Greg - 9/26/2003 6:47:47 AM
        
        still dodging admitting Barry is self contradictory on panspermia I see. (n/t) - Buster - 9/26/2003 3:00:57 AM
        
        re: still dodging admitting Barry is self contradictory on panspermia I see. - Robert Clark - 9/26/2003 1:40:26 PM
        
        this has been done before go back and respond to those older posts and save me some time (n/t) - Buster - 9/26/2003 7:37:02 PM
        
        are you adding commentary or did you not get the point? (n/t) - Buster - 9/25/2003 10:37:53 PM
        
        only 26 rocks from Mars - Greg - 9/26/2003 6:57:20 AM
        
        So did you not read or not get the link that explained why discoveries are such a small fraction of exspected infall? - Buster - 9/26/2003 7:34:47 PM
        
        re: So did you not read or not get the link that explained why discoveries are such a small fraction of exspected infall? - Greg - 9/27/2003 9:43:21 AM
        
        Start here. Ask questions.... - et - 9/26/2003 6:51:17 PM
        
        re: Getting straight - Mark Eby - 9/22/2003 12:33:13 PM
        
        re: Getting straight - Greg - 9/23/2003 4:06:16 AM
        
        Getting impact chronology straight - Nick Hoffman - 9/22/2003 6:02:44 AM
        
        re: Getting impact chronology straight - Greg - 9/23/2003 3:56:05 AM
        
        re: Getting impact chronology straight - BD - 9/23/2003 11:58:51 PM
        
        re: Getting impact chronology straight - Nick Hoffman - 9/23/2003 8:28:39 AM
        
        re: Getting impact chronology straight - Greg - 9/23/2003 3:22:48 PM
        
        re: Getting impact chronology straight - Greg - 9/23/2003 11:04:04 AM
        
        Thanks for trying, but... - Nick Hoffman - 9/23/2003 2:21:07 PM
        
        and a teaser - Greg - 9/23/2003 3:40:57 PM
        
        A teaser indeed! - et - 9/23/2003 6:50:39 PM
        
        btw - Greg - 9/23/2003 4:40:16 AM
        
        "my image" (?) - Nick Hoffman - 9/23/2003 8:31:57 AM
        
        re: "my image" (?) - Greg - 9/23/2003 10:24:53 AM
        
        Ah, I understand. - Nick Hoffman - 9/23/2003 2:18:58 PM
        
        re: Ah, I understand. - Greg - 9/24/2003 3:12:14 AM
- re: "Why A Mars Rock Lands On Earth Every Month" Zubrin's rain of microbes a joke - BD - 9/20/2003 11:34:04 AM
  - Then Hoyle's rain of viruses must be an even bigger joke - R.L. - 9/20/2003 12:50:27 PM
    - re: The Big difference - BD - 9/24/2003 12:18:32 AM
      - The Big difference is actually - Buster - 9/24/2003 1:43:02 AM
    - re: Water/Ice comets much larger than igneous meteor fragments from Mars - BD - 9/23/2003 11:55:25 PM
      - What Comet Coincides With Hoyle's attempt To Link Flu With Space? - Mark Eby - 9/26/2003 3:25:31 PM
    - re: Then Hoyle's rain of viruses must be an even bigger joke - BD - 9/23/2003 11:49:20 PM
      - re: Then Hoyle's rain of viruses must be an even bigger joke - R.L. - 9/24/2003 12:11:46 AM
- aka another meaningless rationalization coupled with insult - E.P.Grondine - 9/20/2003 7:26:35 AM
  - what you thionk is of absolutely no concern to anyone on this board as far as I can tell - Buster - 9/24/2003 1:52:43 AM
  - re: aka another meaningless rationalization coupled with insult - BD - 9/24/2003 12:00:17 AM

Recent posts

On this day in Space/Science

The whole thread (48 posts)

Related discussions