*sigh*
Okay, I'm apparently being too subtle again. Every other liberal that I trotted out that Kerry article for has responded in approximately this fashion: "Who cares what this idiot says? It's just one guy. Nobody else from Kerry's outfit said anything like that. So who are you going to believe?"
In other words, it's one person's story, when all the other people who were there have a different story. Like the man in the story who saw whores in Guantanamo.
Should have been clearer. Did everyone else miss the purpose of the analogy, too?