The more I learn about genetics, the more I realize I, and the rest of science, don't know about how human genetics really works. We apparently have a lot fewer genes than people used to think, and it's beginning to look to me like the genome may be, given the randomness of evolution, an enormous kludge.
Instead of a special gene for one thing, and a different one for another, combinations of genes may do one thing in combination with other genes, and yet other things in combination with other genes.
Altering these combinations artificially in an organism as complicated as a human being are extremely unlikely to have predictable results.
Simple "cloning," if it ever works properly, would seem to avoid a lot of these problems by simply reproducing a "black box," but even that process seems to have unforeseen results. Cloned cats have different color patterns in their coats. There are health problems.
The "argument by design" proof of the existence of God doesn't hold up that well unless you assume God constructs nature like Han Solo constructed the Millennium Falcon. Think along the lines of lots of duct tape.
Speaking of eugenics, did you read the post above on the Scopes Trial?
Off Topic » in reply to Well, in that case, even if there was a point there ..
Eugenics mentality
The whole thread (25 posts)
- The mega rock star of the near future: Mozart's clone
- believing that character and personality can be recreated from DNA alone, is sheer ignorant stupidity
- Anyone with kids knows that at least some personality traits they are born with. (n/t)
- I'm suprised that you haven't read me properly
- I guess even further clarification could be necessary -
- Murphy's Law of the HZ
- Well, I will interpret Tom's absence of reply as complete acquiescence to my point of view
- Genetic Mozart
- Well, I will interpret Tom's absence of reply as complete acquiescence to my point of view
- Murphy's Law of the HZ
- I guess even further clarification could be necessary -
- I'm suprised that you haven't read me properly
- I didn't say "character and personality can be recreated"
- Creativity is a function of CHARACTER and PERSONALITY, which is in the very least, PARTIALLY determined by upbringing and environment
- Creativity and intelligence are developed. They are not ONLY a function of inheritance. It is stupid to think that you can recreate a Mozart just by cloning his DNA. (n/t)
- Character traits seem to be genetically based
- Did you see the Boys from Brazil? (n/t)
- Anyone with kids knows that at least some personality traits they are born with. (n/t)
- believing that character and personality can be recreated from DNA alone, is sheer ignorant stupidity
