Current Events — HabitableZone

Current Events » in reply to re: Iraq experience will be the last time BushCo can pull the wool over peoples' eyes...

you justify US invasion of Iraq, then accept responsibility

for those 100,000 killed in Iraq...
for what? ...
do you think the Iraqi people now give a damn about your ascertions of American justice and 'fair trial' system? Quite frankly, I believe BushCo have overstayed their 'welcome'.

*****

stanibol
not 37,000, estimate: 100,000 plus
Wed Feb 2, 2005 12:13am
198.142.19.107

(link already supplied in above thread)

PR10: Monday 7th November 2004

IBC response to the Lancet study estimating "100,000" Iraqi deaths

Some people have asked us why we have not increased our count to 100,000 in the light of the multiple media reports of the recent Lancet study [link] which claims this as a probable and conservative estimate of Iraqi casualties.

Iraq Body Count does not include casualty estimates or projections in its database. It only includes individual or cumulative deaths as directly reported by the media or tallied by official bodies (for instance, by hospitals, morgues and, in a few cases so far, NGOs), and subsequently reported in the media. In other words, each entry in the Iraq Body Count data base represents deaths which have actually been recorded by appropriate witnesses - not "possible" or even "probable" deaths.

The Lancet study's headline figure of "100,000" excess deaths is a probabilistic projection from a small number of reported deaths - most of them from aerial weaponry - in a sample of 988 households to the entire Iraqi population. Only those actual, war-related deaths could be included in our count. Because the researchers did not ask relatives whether the male deaths were military or civilian the civilian proportion in the sample is unknown (despite the Lancet website's front-page headline "100,000 excess civilian deaths after Iraq invasion", [link] the authors clearly state that "many" of the dead in their sample may have been combatants [P.7]). Iraq Body Count only includes reports where there are feasible methods of distinguishing military from civilian deaths (most of the uncertainty that remains in our own count - the difference between our reported Minimum and Maximum - arises from this issue). Our count is purely a civilian count.

{from the link supplied in the above thread}

Log in or register to post.

The whole thread (15 posts)