whatever is actually going on there - comparing that place to a Gulag, or to Nazi stormtroopers, is 'inaccurate', or more exactly, pure malicious polemicism. Amnesty must have lost a lot of credibility lately, which is a real shame considering how many people are out there who really do need their help

The only valid comparison for 'Gitmo' is to compare it to the values and practices outlined in the US constitution. Im no expert there BTW, but it's obvious that's the only way to go, in evaluating the situation. (yes, while also keeping in mind that most of those incarcerates are either terrorists or terrorist sympathizers)