Science Fiction — HabitableZone

Science Fiction » in reply to Re: So, what do we think of Terra Nova after nine episodes?

Now that's what I'm talking about.

If Terra Nova were meatier, we who take it way too seriously would have something worth talking about.

"It takes a human mind to believe it’s not worthy to live." Profound. We have a rich heritage of finding reasons not to live. Guilt the majority by weight, but concepts of honor/shame and irredeemable sin rank right up there.

In the case of allowing humanity to succumb to self-inflicted ecological disaster, I think that the moral question can be judged somewhat objectively by asking how much else of the Earth's biosphere are we destroying along with ourselves? In other words, is it a victimless crime? Or is there a real victim to be made whole, or future victims to be protected?

Maybe there's a less negative way to rephrase your sentence: It takes a human mind to conceive of a moral framework so broad that it can weigh the rights of one species against the needs of all of a planet's life.

Of course, the jury's still out as to whether the human mind is actually capable of such large-scale thinking. In any case, nature/evolution/Gaia will judge us whether or not we want to be judged.

Log in or register to post.

The whole thread (15 posts)

Related discussions