Yup
I was pleasantly blown away by how good BSG is, compared to how bad the original was. I still think the best scenes are the space battles, but they've made the ongoing plot a lot more sinister and interesting.
I missed the first three or four seasons of SG1 by not owning a TV, but I've caught up since, thanks to the marathon reruns SciFi showed on Monday nights. I'm hooked now -- the characters are thoroughly under my skin.
And that's my problem with SG Atlantis: the characters don't grab me. Maybe the new blood will help.