That would make you a bigot
Change "Born Again Christians" to any other group and you should see the point.
Substitute "blacks" or "homosexuals" for "Born Again Christians" and see how bigoted your words sound. Being "scared" of an entire group of people because of their religion, race, or sexual orientation is bigotry, pure and simple. Being bigoted against people's religious beliefs is still being a bigot, even if it is still "politically correct" in today's environment.