Re: Oh no,...Perhaps both arguments are
correct to some extent and wrong in the sense that they do not address the whole issue or all possibilities. For instance I can speculate that the comets are artificial structures. As 'proof' I can point out that the out gassings look a lot like rocket exhaust and the blue colour tail looks like an ion rocket 'attitude control' exhaust and the very eccentric orbits are the result of deliberate insertion. etc.etc.
The point being that some people will not agree on another persons view point until they experience the truth for them selves. So when speculating, lets take ALL possible explanations into consideration and stop calling each other names. :-)
P.S. I enjoy the excellent info on this board.