Off Topic — HabitableZone

Off Topic » in reply to Depends on your majors.

re: Depends on your majors.

Let's see, I was a political science undergrad (after switching from physics), then got a PhD in the subject.

As an undergrad I was at a top-10 ranked liberal arts college. I took 10 poli sci courses with 8 different professors, and none of them could conceivably be called a Marxist. None of the poli-sci profs were "Marxist" in fact, though maybe one or two of 8 in the History dept could be. The class I took on the politics of the Middle East was taught by a prof who was also an ordained rabbi, an old aquaintance of Israeli diplomat Abba Eban.

As a graduate student taking classes at MIT and Harvard, not one prof I dealt with personally was anything like a Marxist. My advisor was a republican, in fact, and several others were libertarian/free market oriented on economic and regulatory issues, but voted Democratic due to the social conservatism and emphasis on evangelical Christianity of the Republicans.

We did have a prof who left shortly after I arrived who was somewhat self-conciously Marxist in the sense of using that sort of structural economic analysis, but not as a source of political programs -- he wrote about how companies would be shifting to post-industrial, networked and working-empowring forms of organization. Stuff that got assigned in some business schools.

Now, if by "Marxist" Tom would include anyone who favors a Swedish-style welfare state or who opposed SDI in the 1980s, well sure, there were plenty of those. I'd say my profs were about 8 to 1 liberal vs conservative, with a significant minority who would have gone so far as wanting us to emulate European states like Sweden or France.

But if wanting single-payer health care is enough to lump you in with Lenin and Che, than "Marxist" is a term that doesn't mean very much. You might as well say that anyone who favored Bush's tax cuts is an Ayn Rand disciple.

Log in or register to post.

The whole thread (23 posts)