Your study on lunar phases
Very astute observations. Critical thinking.
There's very little in there to argue with, so I agree with most of it.
However, an art is an art. Is there a scientific basis to creativity?
How about predictions?
What about shamans in older aboriginal or indian cultures?
They had the ability to have visions, heal the sick and lead their tribes to safety. Divination has had it's place throughout history. Most people in the tribe respected and honored the tradition without asking for hard scientific proof.