Current Events — HabitableZone

Current Events » in reply to You can't be serious.

Metaphor or deniability?

I'm not jerking your chain, Rob. West is using the classic techniques of a demagogue to incite people to violence while fudging his words just enough to maintain the tiniest of figleaves of deniability. Remember that he was speaking to a crowd with a lot of exservicepeople; in that context, his heavy emphasis on martial imagery and continual references to weaponry is clearly designed to push a particular set of buttons. His words and imagery are very violent.

Can you think of a use for a bayonet other than killing? If he meant some kind of surgical metaphor, he'd have said "scalpel". If his metaphor was about cutting the pie more fairly, he could've referred to a table knife. Hell, if he'd been shooting for something erudite like the Gordian Knot, he'd have referred to a sword.

But he referred to a bayonet. Twice. A weapon invented for the sole purpose of inflicting horrific sucking wounds on an enemy.

You don't see the threat of violence there?

Log in or register to post.

The whole thread (17 posts)

Related discussions