Space/Science — HabitableZone

Space/Science » in reply to Being a chemical engineer does not give you any special capabilites here

It Certainly Impacts My Capabilities But Each Post Should Be Judged On It's Own Merits & Logic
Mark Eby — (archived)

My comments are usually based on technical details. I expect my comments to be judged based on their internal consistency and supporting facts documented in reliable sources supported with links where possible. A well read high school student can and has debunked comments from you and Barry using a similar scientific approach. True science does not recognize credentials only logic and data.

My status as an engineer is of importance only in relevance to posts where credentials come up usually in response to you or Barry quoting the opinion of someone else who supposedly has credentials. If you ask me what relevance my training is I will answer as I did here I do not expect anyone to accept my comments ipso facto based on that training.

This whole line is most amusing coming from the the originator of the famous "shutup because I'm an impact expert" line of reasoning. Try practicing actual rules of scientific debate for a change before preaching about them.

Regards,
Mark

Log in or register to post.

The whole thread (39 posts)