Current Events — HabitableZone

Current Events » in reply to re: First off thanks for a somewhat thoughtful reply

re: First off thanks for a somewhat thoughtful reply
Davin L. — (archived)

"One point that needs comment is the issue of "models". These mathematical simulations of the climate are all very simplistic, when compared to the real thing. None of them include the dominant effects that I mentioned. Many of the researchers who have created these models disagree with each other, more proof to me that the modeling is still at a primitive state."

Pointing out that a mathematical model is simplistic compared to the real thing is, well, duh!. It does not make the model incorrect, nor does it adequately refute the models predictions or hypothesis. To plot the orbit of the planets to remarkable accuracy I need only simple-minded Neutonian Dynamics and a slide rule, and I don't even have to considere relativistic effects. That does not make my predicitons wrong, and guess what- it got voyager to the limits of the solar system!

Your claim that "none of them include the dominant effects" is incorrect. I don't think you are actually read-up on those climate models. Some of them (even going back to the 90s!) even include termites and Cow Farts!

"Even if a house is already burning, it does not help to throw gasoline on the fire.
"

In this we agree!!!

Log in or register to post.

The whole thread (38 posts)