Current Events — HabitableZone

Current Events » in reply to The statement you linked to was from 2004

Correct

The General Casey document (page 7-8) is from 2004 and is relevant. CPA Order 17 was retained as a law of Iraq after the transfer of sovereignty to the Iraqi Interim Government on June 28, 2004.

SDAI-Tech1: ...the Iraqi government is no longer an interim government.

Correct. The Iraqi Interim Government was replaced by the Iraqi Transitional Government in January 2005.

If you visit the U.S. Embassy Baghdad Website and go to the Iraqi Government Links page, there are fifteen links to Websites of the Iraqi Government. The first link is to the "Iraqi Interim Government," which is the Website I linked to in my pervious post. If you view the META keywords tag for the Website, "Iraqi Interim Government" is still listed as a keywords term.

SDAI-Tech1: "Under Iraqi law" refers to the new Iraqi government laws regarding Multi-National-Force soldiers.

I think it refers to the retained CPA Order 17. I don't think Brigadier John Lorimer would cite the CPA order for no good reason.

SDAI-Tech1: So, I suppose my earlier statements about this incident showing Iraq sovereignity are invalid, even though the desire by some to paint the US & British as evil oppressors in any circumstance still is quite valid.

Supposedly, the MNF, since the transfer of sovereignty, is no longer an occupation force and remains in Iraq at the pleasure of the Iraqi government. The government, but not the police or courts, has the power to tell MNF to leave the country.

SDAI-Tech1: Thanks for providing a reasoned & coherent response.

Almost anything for a fellow American.

Log in or register to post.

The whole thread (17 posts)