Disagree With This Part

Mark Eby — 8/17/2006 10:59:38 AM (archived)

"All of these distinguishing characteristics for plutons are scientifically interesting in that they suggest a different origin from the classical planets."

Absolute crap. Their evolution may be different, but their is no reason to believe they did not form from the same primordial cloud as the "classical planets" in the same fashion. The term classical planets is also silly. There is no need for that term and it's inaccurate to include Uranus and Neptune in it. The categories terrestrial planets, gas giants, and plutons or ice dwarfs make sense. The comment above is just a political candy for the Pluto is not a planet crowd.

Overall, I'm pretty happy. It went the way I thought it should except for some minor details about wording and the surprise of Charon which I can live with.

Regards,
Mark

The whole thread (39 posts)

Solar system just got bigger - nick hoffman - 8/16/2006 8:49:36 AM
- No, it didn't... - Pugs - 8/19/2006 4:44:13 AM
- re: Solar system just got bigger - Marcia - 8/17/2006 9:33:05 PM
- Well That Means 3 Visits to Unexplored Planets and a Possible One Are Already Underway - Mark Eby - 8/17/2006 12:34:12 AM
- Cosmic police alert!... Cosmic police alert! - Jacob Samorodin - 8/16/2006 10:42:16 PM
- There goes the neighborhood!! (n/t) - Bowser - 8/16/2006 9:52:46 PM
- Puts an odd spin on the sometimes whacky theories... - alcaray - 8/16/2006 9:04:46 PM
- re: Time to send a probe to Ceres!:-) - Raoul - 8/16/2006 7:15:30 PM
- I think they're working too hard on this. - Tom Brosz - 8/16/2006 5:34:08 PM
- re: It's portrait - Raoul - 8/16/2006 5:20:32 PM
  - re: Pluton - Vince - 8/17/2006 3:06:18 AM
    - re: Pluton - Raoul - 8/17/2006 7:22:36 PM
    - re: Pluton - Fox - 8/17/2006 3:50:26 PM
      - re: Pluton - nick hoffman - 8/19/2006 5:33:10 AM
    - Disagree With This Part - Mark Eby - 8/17/2006 10:59:38 AM
      - re: Disagree With This Part - Vince - 8/18/2006 1:52:31 AM
      - In honor of the IAU decision, I have decided to call little children... - ljk - 8/17/2006 12:53:25 PM
        
        The Ferengi beat you to it (n/t) - Fox - 8/17/2006 3:51:22 PM
        
        re: The Ferengi beat you to it - ljk - 8/17/2006 6:01:52 PM
- Burn the IAU! Heritics! All of them. (n/t) - Abdul hadjii al Terroristanii - 8/16/2006 1:59:28 PM
- re: A discussion from BA - BRFelix - 8/16/2006 1:31:53 PM
- The Simple Definition - ID - 8/16/2006 12:46:01 PM
- re: Solar system just got bigger - BRFelix - 8/16/2006 12:41:05 PM
- Why is Charon going to be a planet? - REB - 8/16/2006 12:26:05 PM
  - Maybe Because It's A Double Planet - ID - 8/16/2006 12:39:32 PM
    - I don't by it. All planet-moon systems orbit the barycenter and not each other. - REB - 8/16/2006 1:21:58 PM
      - Barycenter Inside Planet Versus Outside - ID - 8/16/2006 1:55:34 PM
        
        re: Barycenter Inside Planet Versus Outside - REB - 8/16/2006 1:59:15 PM
        
        re: Barycenter Inside Planet Versus Outside - Robert Clark - 8/17/2006 3:38:11 PM
        
        re: Barycenter Inside Planet Versus Outside - REB - 8/17/2006 4:44:12 PM
        
        re: Barycenter Inside Planet Versus Outside - Robert Clark - 8/17/2006 9:53:37 PM
        
        space.com not spca.com (n/t) - ID - 8/16/2006 1:56:21 PM
- Official - "Planets are Round" - nick hoffman - 8/16/2006 8:51:21 AM
  - Do we have to "obey" the IAU? - LJK - 8/16/2006 1:35:45 PM
    - And the issue is? - Adam - 8/16/2006 9:24:21 PM
    - re: Yes! - Raoul - 8/16/2006 5:27:03 PM
      - When I was a kid... - ljk - 8/17/2006 1:30:47 AM
        
        re: And today things change on a dayly basis - Raoul - 8/17/2006 5:44:56 AM
        
        IAU planetologists not happy with planet naming decision - LJK - 8/18/2006 4:03:04 PM

Recent posts

On this day in Space/Science

The whole thread (39 posts)