Off Topic — HabitableZone

Off Topic » in reply to Interstellar Music

You are taking this way too personally

Do you want us to just nod our heads and say Yes Lindy to whatever you post?

Or do you want us to honestly critique it?

I think the real insult to you would be no one bothering to respond at all.
And that certainly has not been the case.

We'll give the guy a chance, but as I said, he says he picks up music
wherever he aims his radio telescope. Would you trust someone who
says they see UFOs every time they look up at the sky, or sees Bigfoot
every time they walk in the woods?

He has made a claim and now he has to prove it. Nothing less would
be expected of anyone else with such a claim.

I want to do a quote by Carl Sagan that is totally appropriate for
this discussion, but I fear Lindy will blow it all out of proportion.

Log in or register to post.

The whole thread (59 posts)