re: Let's have a go at your analogy, shall we?
Sure. I was here before you I believe, before all these other boards were established.
And I stay off the Space Science Board 350 days a year and do not interfere with your space science, even though others start topics that I probably would, otherwise. I am following the rules.
"Off Topic" has been established as a catch-all for other topics. Just because you or someone else cares to call it "psuedoscience" doesn't mean it is. And this is NOT the basis for the argument. RL's foul, foul mouth and outrageous stalking behaviour around me IS.