Current Events — HabitableZone

Current Events » in reply to Just now reading more about the Bundys

It's tempting to just say they're crazy

...but that doesn't help understand what gets people into these situations.

It's also tempting, when the reasons aren't clear, to ascribe the worst possible motives to people. They're not just crazy, they're evil and malicious. They get off on hurting us. But you describe people who walk right up to that line without being noticeably crazy. Crazy probably isn't a sufficient explanation.

But maybe at the core of what motivates these extreme "patriots" is something actually rather noble, though dangerously deluded. Call it "Founder Envy", or "Revolutionary War cosplay"...but maybe these are people who identify very strongly with the American colonists, while finding the modern world devoid of meaning and value, and in a paroxysm of extreme romanticism, want to live out the Revolution themselves. If that's the underlying, probably hidden goal, then a lot of the rest makes sense. Like having to condemn modern America as fallen from grace, impure, besieged by foreign ideas...substituting the imperialism of modernity for British imperialism. You can't have a revolution without something to rebel against.

This is pretty much just an exercise in amateur psychoanalysis, and I could be imagining it. I can't read minds.

Maybe they are just crazy?

Log in or register to post.

The whole thread (45 posts)

Related discussions