<Of course not. Just pointing out what appears obvious to me. If it is an plasma, it has to move through a medium.
B.S.!!! Where do you come up with such nonsense? If you ionize a material in a vacuum you can accelerate it and have it move through the vacuum... Obviously not a "perfect" vacuum since plasma itself is matter...If you want to argue this with me you will lose because I do it most days of the week... I shoot 1.5kW of infrared laser light into liquid Xenon injected into a fairly good vacuum- heating it to a few dozen times the temp. of the surface of the sun... the ions/plasma move through the vacuum. My PhD work was creating a plasma a few atoms at a time and then moving them down a tube to a detector...
The depth of your ignorance is staggering!
Space is the lack of a medium. In a true vacuume a plasma could not exist.
Space is much more complicated than that! And yes, if you inject a plasma into a vacuum it can exist- you mess up your "perfect" vacuum in doing so because plasma is matter but trust me plasma can move through a vacuum... Again, I speak from first hand experience
In a comet gasses are outgassed from the volatile ices, they are ionized AND DO NOT FORM THE ICE CRYSTALS YOUR REDICULOUS THEORY REQUIRES! They are ionized and when recombination occurs they emit photons... this is NOT reflection... it is EMISSION... This alone disproves your theory.... The ion recombination emits specific frequencies for different atoms/molecules... This emission is seen in the tail and coma and NOT in some diffuse cloud around the nucleus...like your already completely refuted theory would predict! Again-Reflection is not the same as emission!!
The medium the supposed Ion tail appears to be moving through can not exist as a straight line moving mass. It can only be there if it is completely surrounding the comet in 360 degrees and on all axis.
This statement makes NO sense whatsoever!
Then and only then can it be either an electrical show phosphorescing in the darkness of the tail, or a light show caused by refraction of coma reflection.
Do you even know what refraction and reflection mean? The light from the comet tail and coma show EMISSION lines... emission only seen in the coma and tail...
(remember the street lights with the show they put on in the shadow above them?)
FORGET THE D@MN STREETLIGHTS! Totally different phenomenon occurring under drastically different circumstances! If you cannot see this then you are insane! or ignorant, or both I work with plasmas and have researched them in depth... I also know optics since it is my job... your statements make it clear you are completely ignorant on all these subjects.... You are making a fool of yourself... Everyone here knows that you are wrong....There is nothing wrong with speculation, but to hold on to a rediculous idea in the face of the facts is just sad insanity... get a life, move on, and stop wasting our time!!!
Whatever that medium is, it can not move at the speed it appears to move either latterally to or in line with the solar winds.
prove it.... you make ignorant statements of what is and isn't possible, back it up buddy- prove that you know more than those that actually do real science...
In another analogy, think of the beam of light coming from a light house. If the air is clear, you do not see the beam as it swings around in a 360 degree circle unless you look directly at the light. But if there is a slight haze in the air you can see the beam of light and it appears to move through the air, fairly slowly near to the light house and much faster at a long distance from the light house.
another FLAWED analogy... if you spectrally resolved the observed beam you will see it resembles the spectrum of the lighthouse.... but you look at the spectrum of the ion trail it does not reflect the spectrum of the sun...
Now try to imagine a situation in which there is no mist in the air except in the beam of light and it is able to move laterally with the beam. That is what you are expected to believe is happening in the so called Ion tail of a comet under the accepted theories. It is like thinking the mist is being shot from the lighthouse at the speed of light. Quantum Physics, gravitaional and orbital physics all say that it is not possible.
It is clear that your understanding of physics is inferior to that of many teenagers I have known... You are wasting board space- you will not convince ANYONE here....
You are a sad waste of space, stick with your wireless internet business... you have proven you are incapable of applying the scientific method.... you just have a sad need to be "right" and it has possessed you to the point that you will deny all reason... I am sure you will whine that you are still right even though it has been proven that you are insanely wrong.... I am sorry you feel so desperate to make a real discovery... and that you are too lazy to actually educate yourself so that you can speak without appearing a fool... education has a purpose... but silly rantings such as yours just waste our time...
Thats all....
Space/Science » in reply to Re: That's exactly how plasma works . . .
Apted you have NO idea how a plasma "works"
The whole thread (31 posts)
- Ze comète....a movie!
- I wish the movie was longer. :}
- Danke! Das ist fantastish!
- Re: Is it really moving, or just looking like it?
- Re: Not dust. Pure ion . . .
- Re: Ze comète....a movie!
