Space/Science — HabitableZone

Space/Science » in reply to The answer is more complicated than that

A Tired and Suspect Excuse

The questions were one sentence yes or no answer type. You have spent far more time repeating the same thing over and over than it would take to answer those questions. I don't buy your excuse anymore although I was willing to accept it prior to the post listed at the beginning of this thread.

Complicated subjects often require covering a lot of ground. Something your "the model's not validated" mantra overlooks.

Perhaps it's not time that's the issue, but your willingness to actually reconsider your position. Comments from you, PW, Phil Chapman, and Tom B caused me to start paying more attention to the issue and question my on thoughts. Every issue you guys have raised I have tried to follow up on, but the more I hear you and others repeat the same thing over and over without new thought and without any thoughtful reply to the issues I've raised as counterpoints the less I think your position is based on reason.

Regards,
Mark

Log in or register to post.

The whole thread (29 posts)