All that matters is what the Supreme Court says. And the Supreme Court says that the Second Amendment includes the words "well regulated militia" because it means "well regulated militia".

No doubt had they meant "every inadequate redneck with no impulse control" or "every anal retentive arch-conservative" they would have said "every inadequate redneck with no impulse control" or "every anal retentive arch-conservative". But, they haven't, yet.

Funny how easy it is to believe the Supreme Court, including Scalia and his hand-puppet Thomas when they agree with you, and how hard it is when they don't.

By the way, Thomas voted differently than Scalia the other day. It was news.

Arf