Current Events — HabitableZone

Current Events » in reply to re: It ain't "the Left."

No wonder. It's subtle, and there's a principle involved.

Bowser - The QUALITY of the acts is the same as Hussein if the QUANTITY isn't.

T. B. - By this thesis, a Klansman shooting a Jew is equivalent to the Holocaust. While neither is excusable, the equivalence doesn't stand up very well. Even the "quality" doesn't stand up very well.

To the Jew, it's the same. The hatred is the same. Your implication is that the one Jew's life isn't as tragically lost unless it's part of a larger whole. Many people would disagree, and might argue that the larger whole was composed of many indivuduals, each of whom held life as dear as anyone else.

And the punishment is usually the same. Hopefully, the Klansman will hang for one life as high as the SS man for 6,000,000.

I don't understand being able to discriminate between the quality of the one vs. the quality of the other. A bit like my rape analogy. Both are rapists. And the one is a hypocrite and rapist.

Unless in one it's the State, and in the other it's a voluntary group.

Sorta like Iraq. There it was the State.

Arf

Log in or register to post.

The whole thread (17 posts)