Larry Swings at 1 Out of 7

Space/Science » in reply to Once again, you invoke political dogma as a substitute for sound science

Larry Swings at 1 Out of 7

Mark Eby — 7/25/2002 2:57:29 PM (archived)

Larry,

Forgot to mention you addressed only 1 point out of 7. Did you agree with the article on the other 5 issues I criticised?

I did give it credit for one good counter argument. It made sense to me even if it didn't to Alcaray. However, given the flaws in the author's logic elsewhere I'm not at all sure that modeling failure is actually significant. The amount of energy retained in the portion of atmosphere deviating from models even if true is probably a small portion of the total retained given the much lower density of the upper atmosphere.

Regards,
Mark

The whole thread (38 posts)

Computer Simulations & the Climate - p - 7/24/2002 3:17:28 PM
- One odd point from your link - alcaray - 7/24/2002 6:44:03 PM
  - Phil's Got You - Mark Eby - 7/24/2002 12:09:43 PM
    - In this case... - alcaray - 7/25/2002 3:21:40 PM
  - Re: One odd point from your link - p - 7/24/2002 8:47:54 AM
    - Re: One odd point from your link - alcaray - 7/24/2002 9:46:56 AM
- Interesting. - ebnelson - 7/24/2002 4:19:43 PM
  - Re: Interesting. - Robert E. B. - 7/24/2002 5:14:41 PM
    - Remember you equilibrium equations Robert - Mark Eby - 7/24/2002 3:47:48 PM
- Goofy and goofier. - Bowser - 7/24/2002 4:13:57 PM
  - Good and funny (and ignored) analogy! n/t (n/t) - alcaray - 7/24/2002 6:40:34 PM
    - Re: Ignored analogy - Tom Brosz - 7/24/2002 11:23:44 AM
      - Your analogy was excellent, too - alcaray - 7/25/2002 3:25:37 PM
        
        Re: analogy - Tom Brosz - 7/25/2002 9:42:55 AM
        
        One day soon I will respond to this - alcaray - 7/26/2002 3:41:40 PM
        
        Re: One day soon I will respond to this - Tom Brosz - 7/26/2002 5:08:14 PM
        
        Kyoto Smyoto - Mark Eby - 7/25/2002 2:43:38 PM
        
        Re: Kyoto Smyoto - Tom Brosz - 7/25/2002 4:39:23 PM
        
        That's Still No Excuse - Mark Eby - 7/26/2002 4:16:15 PM
      - The old - - - - Bowser - 7/24/2002 11:49:21 AM
      - No - Mark Eby - 7/24/2002 11:47:40 AM
  - Re: Goofy - Tom Brosz - 7/24/2002 4:43:06 PM
- Cooked Books? - Mark Eby - 7/24/2002 3:45:00 PM
- Sure Let's Overlook The Obvious & Bury Our Heads - Mark Eby - 7/24/2002 11:43:31 AM
  - Once again, you invoke political dogma as a substitute for sound science - Larry J - 7/25/2002 1:23:57 PM
    - Re: Once again, you invoke political dogma as a substitute for sound science - delbert - 7/25/2002 7:09:53 PM
      - Re: Once again, you invoke political dogma as a substitute for sound science - gbaikie - 7/25/2002 3:01:47 PM
        
        Re: Once again, you invoke political dogma as a substitute for sound science - gbaikie - 7/25/2002 3:20:44 PM
    - Larry Swings at 1 Out of 7 - Mark Eby - 7/25/2002 2:57:29 PM
      - I don't have time to respond to an encyclopedia - Larry J - 7/26/2002 8:05:55 AM
        
        Yet You Seem To Support Policy Based on Wishful Thinking Alone - Mark Eby - 7/26/2002 4:07:56 PM
        
        computer models are done by people - p - 7/27/2002 7:11:31 PM
        
        So are rockets, brain surgery, etc - Mark Eby - 7/27/2002 9:47:05 AM
        
        I never said that and I resent you trying to put words in my mouth. - Larry J - 7/27/2002 10:07:30 AM
        
        What Your Words Mean Not What You Said. - Mark Eby - 7/27/2002 2:44:33 PM
        
        Re: Computer Models - SDAI-Tech1 - 7/27/2002 6:15:44 PM
        
        Equations Are Old & Model Consistency Tests Are Well Established - Mark Eby - 7/28/2002 6:05:09 PM
    - Handwaving Away Arguments A Sign Of Dogma - Mark Eby - 7/25/2002 12:19:18 PM

Recent posts

On this day in Space/Science

The whole thread (38 posts)