Current Events — HabitableZone

Current Events » in reply to Re: fear and respect cont'd

Chomsky

<...I guess you must be anti-American if you don't maintain a high approval rating for Duhbya. To want to have a better country must be wrong. All change must be wrong---too bad it is inevitable!

Oh, give it a rest. You know perfectly well the kind of opinions Chomsky has, and they go a good parsec past simple "disapproval" of our nation and our president. Chomsky doesn't want a "better country." He wants America dead and eaten by worms, and grousing about disagreement with simple opposing opinions isn't appropriate.

You sound like a six year old kid complaining "you never let me do anything" when he wants to set fire to the cat.

From a David Horowitz column on Chomsky:

...The illusion that socialism promises a better future is also the cause of the Chomsky cult. It is the illusion at the heart of the messianic hope that creates the progressive left. This hope is a chimera, but insofar as it is believed, history presents itself in terms that are Manichaean -- as a battle between good and evil. Those who oppose socialism, Marxism, Communism embody worldly evil. They are the party of Satan, and their leader America is the Great Satan himself.



Chomsky is, in fact, the imam of this religious worldview on today’s college campuses. His great service to the progressive faith is to deny the history of the last hundred years, which is the history of progressive atrocity and failure. In the 20th century, progressives in power killed one hundred million people in the attempt to realize their impossible dream. As far as Noam Chomsky is concerned, these catastrophes of the left never happened. "I don’t much like the terms left and right," Chomsky writes in yet another ludicrous screed called The Common Good. "What’s called the left includes Leninism [i.e., Communism], which I consider ultra-right in many respects…. Leninism has nothing to do with the values of the left – in fact, it’s radically opposed to them."

You have to pinch yourself when reading sentences like that.

The purpose of such Humpty-Dumpty mutilations of the language is perfectly intelligible, however. It is to preserve the faith for those who cannot live without some form of the Communist creed. Lenin is dead. Long live Leninism. The Communist catastrophes can have "nothing to do with the values of the left" because if they did the left would have to answer for its deeds and confront the fact that it is morally and intellectually bankrupt. Progressives
would have to face the fact that they killed 100 million people for nothing -- for an idea that didn’t work.

The real threat of a good example is the threat of America, which has lifted more people out of poverty -- within its borders and all over the world -- than all the socialists and progressives put together since the beginning of time. To neutralize the threat, it is necessary to kill the American idea. This is, in fact, Noam Chomsky’s mission in life, and his everlasting disgrace.



This has a lot of similarity to what I wrote earlier.

Part one of the column can be found here if anyone is curious.

Log in or register to post.

The whole thread (29 posts)