Current Events — HabitableZone

Current Events » in reply to "There never was any connection between Iraq and al Qaeda"

"connection" vs. "link"

It's probably time to get grounded with the dictionary, since the disagreement is starting to become about semantics."Link" and "connection" are closely-related words, but the subtle difference between them is crucial to this discussion.

link
1 : a connecting structure: as a (1) : a single ring or division of a chain (2) : one of the standardized divisions of a surveyor's chain that is 7.92 inches (20.1 centimeters) long and serves as a measure of length b : CUFF LINK c : BOND 3c d : an intermediate rod or piece for transmitting force or motion; especially : a short connecting rod with a hole or pin at each end e : the fusible member of an electrical fuse
2 : something analogous to a link of chain: as a : a segment of sausage in a chain b : a connecting element or factor [found a link between smoking and cancer] c : a unit in a communication system d : an identifier attached to an element (as an index term) in a system in order to indicate or permit connection with other similarly identified elements


con·nec·tion
1 : the act of connecting : the state of being connected : as a : causal or logical relation or sequence <the connection between two ideas> b (1) : contextual relation or association [in this connection the word has a different meaning] (2) : relationship in fact <wanted in connection with a robbery> c : a relation of personal intimacy (as of family ties) d : COHERENCE, CONTINUITY
2 a : something that connects : LINK [a loose connection in the wiring] b : a means of communication or transport
3 : a person connected with another especially by marriage, kinship, or common interest [has powerful connections]
4 : a political, social, professional, or commercial relationship: as a : POSITION, JOB b : an arrangement to execute orders or advance interests of another [a firm's foreign connections] c : a source of contraband (as illegal drugs)
5 : a set of persons associated together: as a : DENOMINATION b : CLAN
- con·nec·tion·al /-shn&l, -sh&-n&l/ adjective


"Link" is even listed as a synonym for connection, but in the form of a "loose connection". I think the differrence between the two words is the strength of the link/connection--a "connection" is stronger than a link and establishes a relationship. That's crucial.

I would say that Iraq and al Qaeda are linked through the simple fact that they had contacts: al Qaeda approached Iraq for help, but were turned down.

But they never had a connection, because they never established a relationship.

Links are tenuous things, and through the Doctrine of Six Degrees of Kevin Bacon, we're all linked to one degree or another. I have links on some Web pages to NASA Web sites, but I don't have a connection to--that is, a relationship with--NASA.

It's a bit of misdirection to focus on what Bush explicitly said. His right-hand man (or puppeteer, depending on your view) Dick Cheney said emphatically that Iraq and al Qaeda had an ongoing relationship, and that's flatout contradicted by the 9/11 commission reports. And, ahem, Bush and Cheney have a clear documented connection--when the Vice President "misspeaks", the Bush Administration "misspeaks".

I'm afraid I can't qualify what I said before: There never was any connection between Iraq and al Qaeda.

Log in or register to post.

The whole thread (37 posts)