Gas, cont.
Unfortunately, the "realm of ideas" often has to deal with the real world. You can keep your Hegelian idealized methods of arriving at a synthesis (which aren't really "Hegelian" anyway). Out in the real world we are dealing with existence and non-existence, and the idea that every conflict has a workable compromise falls flat in many cases.
Incidentally, this brilliant and elaborate fandango of yours does nothing to negate my original criticism of your position.