Off Topic — HabitableZone

Off Topic » in reply to Music from Space Part III

We were discussing Johannes' crackpot theory.
alcaray — (archived)

It is an old and recurring pastime, around here. At the time, I did not know enough about you or your beliefs to have an informed opinion.

Your latest post seems to claim that it includes proof that your musical messages are created by ETIs, if I understand correctly. I do not see that proof. I don't think that your post aludes to proofs outside of the post either. I would love to see such proof and I would dearly love to hear from ETs.

I also think that there's not a shred of the em spectrum that is "ignored" by astronomers. That these astronomers do not think there is anything to investigate in your claim means only that there are two points of view in play. If you come up with something that resembles proof, you will find a great deal of interest in your idea.

There is a whole field of study that seeks to differentiate between random noise and intellegible signal. Submit your signals to those algorithms and see what happens, is my advice. That would be evidence of something extraordinary, if they showed a probability of a non-random source for them.

Log in or register to post.

The whole thread (87 posts)