While I've had a strroke, which has pretty severely affected both motor control and short term memory, there's some things I can remember, including some of you and your little friends' stunts.
Look Mars Boy, I spoke with some of Musk's engineers before he ever started on this, a long long time back.
As fars as Musk goes, and what he intends to do with Falcon, all I want to tell you is that you keep forgetting the Moon.
Now you do not want to believe this, but then you've never taken a look at peroxide/alcohol propellant systems. (By the way, hypergolics appear to have won, at leasst for now.)
Perhaps Musk has changed his views since then, but I haven't.
As far as Zubrin goes, while in situ fuel manufacture may be possible or not, due to dust or other factors, tha is something we don't know yet. Golidin had this plan for MISRU, but then he became a whipping boy for the neo-fascist Wrecking Crew, with help from some hytserical ninnies. Goldin actually intended to land men on Mars by 2020 with a shuttle derived vehicle.
Zubrin underestimated both radiation shielding and life support in his mass requirements- its a common fault of space fantasists.
And neither he nor you can simply wave away back contamination with hand waving rationalizations.
And as far as launching a large nuclear reactor with Ares 5 , you can forget it. As far as using the Moon simply to test manned Mars systems, well Griffin's gone, and good riddance.
Bottom line: As far as the super heavy Zubrin wanted, its not in Musk's plans. Period.
Space/Science » in reply to Do You Ever Bother To Get Facts Straight?
On this one, yeah
The whole thread (30 posts)
- SpaceX founder dreams of colonizing Mars
- re: SpaceX founder dreams of colonizing Mars
- You left out the Moon again (n/t)
- There's a big difference between Musk and Zubrin
- You're Not An Engineer So Stop Pretending You Have A Clue About Engineering
- Evading the evidence, and throw in a personal attack
- Just The Facts
- Just The Facts
- Do You Ever Bother To Get Facts Straight?
- On this one, yeah
- Let's See If Taking It one Item At a Time Will be Simple Enough For You
- Let's See If Taking It one Item At a Time Will be Simple Enough For You
- [OK, Guys, simmer down]
- Let's See If Taking It one Item At a Time Will be Simple Enough For You
- On this one, yeah
- Do You Ever Bother To Get Facts Straight?
- Just The Facts
- Just The Facts
- Evading the evidence, and throw in a personal attack
- You're Not An Engineer So Stop Pretending You Have A Clue About Engineering
