Off Topic — HabitableZone

Off Topic » in reply to Re: Wishes of the left...

Re: Wishes of the left...

We may be missing the simplest answer...the reason Utopian novels aren't written often is because by definition in a Utopia there are no problems to be faced and solved, which is the essence of any good story.

A libertarian Utopian SF novel would probably be L. Neil Smith's "Probability Broach" series. It doesn't describe a perfect society, but does describe using libertarian solutions to solve the problems that come up. Same for "Atlas Shrugged," which is an idealized conflict between collectivism and individualism, and shows a "Utopia" only briefly in Galt's Gulch. Obviously, while it's interesting to see an individualist society played out, a whole novel set there would bore the reader to death.

People want to see conflict in stories. Everybody remembers Dante's "Inferno." Who cared about his "Purgatorio" and "Paradiso?" Boring!

Log in or register to post.

The whole thread (37 posts)