As I said before- I read the paper, the criticism, and their reponse to the criticism...
It's PEER REVIEw...
And just to set the record straight Svensmark does not say anthropogenic global warming isn't happening, he is saying that the sun's influence on CR's is as important as or more important than Carbon dioide... A claim that has MUCH evidence against it.
They have a contraversial theory, they published it, no one stopped them, and BECAUSE it as contraversial it got an interview in a leading popular science magazine, they seem to have plans to get more data- where is conspiracy to silence them?
It seems to be an illustration of the process working as it should! If you think a harsh criticism is over the line, well, all I can tell you I have seen worse over far less contraversial claims.