Space/Science — HabitableZone

Space/Science » in reply to Yeah, the failure of MPL could have been avoided if they used an entirely different landing system.

re: Yeah, the failure of MPL could have been avoided if they used an entirely different landing system.

"On the other hand the Beagle 2 would have been a success if they used the more robust airbags NASA used, with a relatively small increase in cost."

Couldnt happen. Not enough mass. Everyone is very quick to say "Bigger chutes" "Bigger airbags" "A transmitter during decent" - All things that were technically impossible due to mass constraints involved. It's mass that killed B2 imho - there's a limit below which you just cant do Mars Landings without excessive risk. 100kg you could do a whole lot more to ensure a safe landing. It was always ambitious, always risky, but always, imho, worth a try.

Doug

Log in or register to post.

The whole thread (46 posts)