These are difficult issues.
In any area of health where something has as much potential for subjectivity as this, diagnosis is hard, and so is preventing potential abuse of such diagnoses.
My own experience isn't with these syndromes, but with things like ADHD in the education system. It seems apparent to me that the diagnosis in recent years has been widened beyond real needs. The temptation to do that is great: doctors have a hammer, and start to see nails everywhere, especially when patients are demanding something "real" and specific as a diagnosis. Pharmaceutical companies want to sell the medicines. Teachers see a quick medical solution for something that might otherwise take a lot of work and a lot of time they don't have for one student.
I have no background in PTSD, but I would imagine the potential for this sort of abuse can be found here, too. Add to that the financial issues involved, and the political baggage (from both sides of the aisle), and it gets even worse.
Flame » in reply to PTSD and TBI
re: PTSD and TBI
The whole thread (112 posts)
- Garrison Keillor gets ripped a new one
- I wonder what he would think of an Irish wake? (n/t)
- Amazing!
- What did Keillor say? Your link doesn't go there.
- Once again, TB, you've done your part to heal our divisions and bring us together as a nation. (n/t)
- Garrison Keillor is right.
- re: Garrison Keillor
- There you do, generalizing again.
- Musings on memorial day
- veterans
- re: veterans
- Lies, damned lies, and statistics
- Ah. The "not increasing as fast as we think it should be" cut. A classic.
- Try to hold on to a little perspective
- From the other post you ignored...
- But PTSD isn't real.
- re: But PTSD isn't real.
- re: But PTSD isn't real. (n/t)
- Having trouble keeping track of the thread, Banjo Boy?
- I prefer a steel guitar. (n/t)
- Huh, So he did.
- Want to know why I ignored it?
- But PTSD isn't real.
- Ah. The "not increasing as fast as we think it should be" cut. A classic.
- Lies, damned lies, and statistics
- "the dispiriting lie"
- That reporter is wrong.
- Prove it
- For the record.
- Where do you get off...
- Oh gee, I dunno...
- Not a lie.
- But not the truth, either
- And it's not just about spit
- The site that is from has a vietnam veteran's story where he specifically says "I never had anyone spit on me upon my return from Vietnam."- any particular reason you didnt mention that fact? (n/t)
- And you want vindication of your side by ignoring an ugly truth.
- Not a lie.
- Yeah, Robert!!! His uncles could be decent human beings, nothing like Lee at all.... (n/t)
- Oh gee, I dunno...
- Prove it
- re: veterans
- re: Garrison Keillor
- What a pile of slanderous crap...
- ER
- re: Garrison Keillor
- Er...did your links lead to the intended destinations? (n/t)
- He's so far ahead in that department he'll never be caught. (n/t)
