Whenever God enters the room,
...Theology comes in the door as well. It's unavoidable, like the camel's nose in the tent. Is the rest of the camel far behind?
I appreciate your position as an agnostic, but the thread is still funny. Any attempt to prove or disprove God's existence or actions based on science is funny. Science isn't a God subject, and God isn't a science subject. Either you believe or you don't. Simple, really. There are lots of very good scientists who are nevertheless believers, and it doesn't get in the way of their work at all because they aren't religious literalists.
This is exactly where the fight over God in the classroom gets into trouble.