Off Topic — HabitableZone

Off Topic » in reply to I try to stick with "hat." It ain't always easy.

What do you think of SDAI-Tech1's conclusion?

Despite arriving at the conclusion that Americ is too big to function well through a bogus path, he's not the first person to wonder about that. I certainly have.

I'm not sure that extreme Federalism is the answer, because the 50 states are, most of them, individually too small; it's the opposite extreme, foregoing economies of scale and a large collective resource base to fund a huge collective military (the common defense), not to mention initiatives to promote the general welfare. Our system is a lot like an insurance pool, and the effectiveness of insurance pools depends on the size of the resources they can aggregate.

What about the old notion of "The Seven States of North America"? Such a system would probably still require a common security framework, but seven regional-scale nations would be big enough to take care of their own domestic needs.

Log in or register to post.

The whole thread (84 posts)