I know that any point I make here will simply roll off you, but if you would stop scoffing at "phycological effects" for a second and think about what Phycological effects really does as far as acheiving victory with minimal casualties, you would realize a very important point.
just sit there and think about it. . . give it some time. . . you know the military has whole units devoted to this (Phy-Ops)
now: for the rest you said:
It's weird that some people are having a hard time with the term "weapon of mass destruction", and dragging in shotguns and handgrenades and weapons of every type.
See my response to Raoul, I agree, shotguns and handguns as WMD are silly, and so is Napalm. I explained why.
Which word in that phrase is unclear? Napalm is a weapon, and its destruction is indiscriminate on a mass scale. It inflicts pain and suffering on a par with nuclear, biological, and chemical weapons. Napalm is most definitely not a humane weapon.
name a humane weapon!!!! What about the Battle Axe? how would you like to die from being partially cleaved in half? How about a nice fat mini ball from the civil war tearing open your stomach so you can see your breakfast spilling out all over the floor and the HCL burning your skin? There are NO HUMANE WEAPONS. The very idea of trying to kill people humanely wreacks of pure idiocy.
The 9/11 hijackers in effect used napalm on the Pentagon and the Towers. Are all you defenders of napalm defending their choice of weapon? If its use by the US is moral and perfectly acceptable, was it moral and acceptable for the 9/11 hijackers to use a very similar weapon?
Give me a break! you are against 911 because the terrorist used jet feul to kill 3000 people? 3000 noncombatants killed in peacetime is wrong. What difference does it make which weapon they used? NONE.
Flame » in reply to Surely you jest
Phycological effects
The whole thread (183 posts)
- Immoral
- re: The immorality of napalm usage depends upon what you would consider a moral war . . .
- Nope. You just find excuses
- This thread is certainly easier to follow in 1024 x 768 display mode (n/t)
- The epitome of flame wars! Robert please add this to the hall o' flame!(nt) (n/t)
- You've only scratched the surface, bud
- fwiw, welcome Zhavric...and to Raoul...
- re: You've only scratched the surface, bud
- Actually...
- re: Actually...
- Since its flame, and you are acting
- Wow...
- re: Wow...
- Listen
- Dear Stupid
- re: What . . . ?
- Abandon all integrity oh ye who enter the hollow passage of the Right Wing Mind
- Let me clear it up for you...
- re: Listen
- Listen
- Chamberlain and Hitler were also chummy...
- re: Wow...
- re: Actually...
- Actually...
- My two cents worth on this
- re: Stupid
- re: Immoral
- Immoral
- Napalm is nasty stuff..
- As long as hairs are being split
- Splitting hairs way too finely
- OK, name a great way to die, and one that doesn't take up medical resources (n/t)
- Surely you jest
- yeagh, napalm is bad, but wait till you see what a chemical weapon can do!!
- re: the Burn Unit
- Ok then, name an explosive that won't burn anyone (n/t)
- re: No. YOU tell me what justifies the use of a weapon whose specific intent is to burn people.
- re: the Burn Unit
- Ok then, name an explosive that won't burn anyone (n/t)
- Let's review the situation
- re: the Burn Unit
- re: Surely you jest
- Phycological effects
- yeagh, napalm is bad, but wait till you see what a chemical weapon can do!!
- Well...
- Surely you jest
- Oh come on Robert
- "terror is as terror does"
- Shotguns were widely used by American troops in Vietnam...
- By your definition, we should get rid of everything but pea shooters.
- Shoehorned??
- re: "terror is as terror does"
- "terror is as terror does"
- OK, name a great way to die, and one that doesn't take up medical resources (n/t)
- I love the smell of napalm in the morning.
- re: Remember?
- It smells like children on fire.
- re: Funny girl . . .
- The same could be said about any weapon.
- Lee proves himself to be a P.O.S. yet again
- Oh man!
- I had a uncle killed in Vietnam by a 10 year old.
- re: I had a uncle killed in Vietnam by a 10 year old.
- The only good gook is a dead gook?
- re: The only good gook is a dead gook?
- re: The only good gook is a dead gook?
- re: The only good gook is a dead gook?
- an odd question, given the person.
- I'm sure the children of Hamburg and Berlin had the same look on their faces too.
- I had a uncle killed in Vietnam by a 10 year old.
