"Basically you're taking the morally craven position that the end justifies the means"
I'm not taking a "morally craven position". I'm correcting your misinformed impression of the definition of the word "Terror". Because it seemed to me that you think terror is "really scaring someone" and therefore with this childish definition you can't even begin to address this issue.
"Seems, gb, that not even the Pentagon would defend its use of napalm as shamelessly as you would. They'd rather lie than admit to it, which is to their credit, in a twisted way; but what's your excuse? "
As Miltary has stated it doesn't use napalm. And is a lie to state that miltary does continue using napalm. Napalm is a specific thing. Sometimes people use terms loosely therefore it's understandable why someone might think the US miltary still uses napalm. But actual true fact is the miltary not longer uses napalm. And it is it probably illegal according to some law passed by the Congress for the miltary to use napalm. Therefore it's understandable why the Pentagon would correct the reporter [reporters generally seem to like to promote stories about how the US miltary does things illegally- it's similar to "man bites dog type stories".] Now, the Congress isn't likely to pass laws against the Miltary using incendiaries bombs, but if it did, the miltary will follow the laws passed by Congress. Of course, it possible if Congress restricted the miltary in this fashion, that several generals may resign in protest- at least, I can hope that some would have the balls to do this.
Flame » in reply to "terror is as terror does"
re: "terror is as terror does"
The whole thread (183 posts)
- Immoral
- re: The immorality of napalm usage depends upon what you would consider a moral war . . .
- Nope. You just find excuses
- This thread is certainly easier to follow in 1024 x 768 display mode (n/t)
- The epitome of flame wars! Robert please add this to the hall o' flame!(nt) (n/t)
- You've only scratched the surface, bud
- fwiw, welcome Zhavric...and to Raoul...
- re: You've only scratched the surface, bud
- Actually...
- re: Actually...
- Since its flame, and you are acting
- Wow...
- re: Wow...
- Listen
- Dear Stupid
- re: What . . . ?
- Abandon all integrity oh ye who enter the hollow passage of the Right Wing Mind
- Let me clear it up for you...
- re: Listen
- Listen
- Chamberlain and Hitler were also chummy...
- re: Wow...
- re: Actually...
- Actually...
- My two cents worth on this
- re: Stupid
- re: Immoral
- Immoral
- Napalm is nasty stuff..
- As long as hairs are being split
- Splitting hairs way too finely
- OK, name a great way to die, and one that doesn't take up medical resources (n/t)
- Surely you jest
- yeagh, napalm is bad, but wait till you see what a chemical weapon can do!!
- re: the Burn Unit
- Ok then, name an explosive that won't burn anyone (n/t)
- re: No. YOU tell me what justifies the use of a weapon whose specific intent is to burn people.
- re: the Burn Unit
- Ok then, name an explosive that won't burn anyone (n/t)
- Let's review the situation
- re: the Burn Unit
- re: Surely you jest
- Phycological effects
- yeagh, napalm is bad, but wait till you see what a chemical weapon can do!!
- Well...
- Surely you jest
- Oh come on Robert
- "terror is as terror does"
- Shotguns were widely used by American troops in Vietnam...
- By your definition, we should get rid of everything but pea shooters.
- Shoehorned??
- re: "terror is as terror does"
- "terror is as terror does"
- OK, name a great way to die, and one that doesn't take up medical resources (n/t)
- I love the smell of napalm in the morning.
- re: Remember?
- It smells like children on fire.
- re: Funny girl . . .
- The same could be said about any weapon.
- Lee proves himself to be a P.O.S. yet again
- Oh man!
- I had a uncle killed in Vietnam by a 10 year old.
- re: I had a uncle killed in Vietnam by a 10 year old.
- The only good gook is a dead gook?
- re: The only good gook is a dead gook?
- re: The only good gook is a dead gook?
- re: The only good gook is a dead gook?
- an odd question, given the person.
- I'm sure the children of Hamburg and Berlin had the same look on their faces too.
- I had a uncle killed in Vietnam by a 10 year old.
